1776-Unknown constable
1811-High Constable John F. Ruhe Jr.
1854-High Constable William Horn
1867-High Constable Jacob M. Ruhe
1869-High Constable Emanuel Hoffert
1871-High Constable William H. Kleckner
1874-High Constable William H. Hilyard
1875-Title changed to Chief of Police.
Chief of Police Daniel S. Gift
1878-Tilghman Good
1884-Preston J. Baker
1886-James W. Craden
1888-Newton H. Bieber and William W. Heberling
1890-Daniel S. Gift
1893-William D. Mickley
1896-Patrick Herrity
1899-Patrick McGee
1902-Harry H. Eastman
1905-1908-George Smith, William P. Bowen and Milton Schadt
1908-Herman Benning and William A. Hersh
1909-Charles D. Rhoads
1912-1928-Milton H. Bernard (served 20 years)
Position of Assistant Chief created.
1932-1936-No Chief of Police but a Commissioner who was Frank Beary.
During this time there was also a Superintendent who was Patrick Herrity.
1936-Chief of Police Clarence R. Mensinger
1940-Arthur V. Yohe
1944-Wayne Elliott
1948-James L. Christine
1952-Anthony L. Reilly
1956-James L. Christine
Position of Inspector created.
1960-Walter C. Wickert
1961-Gerald M. Monahan Sr.
Second longest serving police chief (served 9 years)
1970-Ralph T. Kressley and Carson S. Gable
1978-Charles Charles and Arthur A. Allender
1982-Carson S. Gable returned as Chief.
1987-David Howells Sr.
1992-Wayne Stephens
1994-John Stefanic
1996-Gerald Monahan Jr.
1998-Paul Snyder and Carl Held
2002-Stephen Kuhn
2004-Joseph Blackburn
2006-Roger J. MacLean
2013-Joseph Hanna and Joel Fitzgerald
2015-Keith Morris